Best Eye Makeup Removers for Sensitive eyes

The 12 Best Eye Makeup Removers for Sensitive eyes

Think about the number of times you use makeup in a regular week.

Think about how many times you need to apply and re-apply your eyeliner and eyeshadow. Chances are that you might be doing it multiple times a day.

With so many instances of having to use makeup, there’s a high probability that the following situation has played out:

Used an old, clumpy mascara because you’re in a hurry?

Filled in your eyebrows so that you look like a clown?

Eyeliner doesn’t match on both eyes?

  • Don’t worry! There’s a solution to the problem!

All you need to do is search for some eye makeup remover and all shall be well. Just get a cotton bud and rub it off, then start again.

  • Wait a minute…

Is it even working? Why isn’t anything coming off? Do I need to rub harder?

Did you get some in your eyes? Do you feel like your skin is burning?

Are you reacting badly to an ingredient in your makeup remover? Are you using the right type of remover for the job?

Unfortunately, these are the problems that arise all too often when using eye makeup remover.

Best Eye Makeup Remover: Comprehensive Ratings Chart

Product Image

Product / Rating

Check Price

Full Reviews

The Body Shop Camomile

The Body Shop Camomile Gentle Eye Makeup Remover


MAC Gently Off Eye & Lip Makeup Remover


Nivea Double Effects Eye Makeup Remover


NARS Gentle Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover


Avon Moisture Effective Eye Makeup Remover Lotion

L'Oréal Paris Gentle

L'Oréal Paris Gentle Eye Makeup Remover

Philosophy Purity

Philosophy Purity Made Simple


Shiseido Instant Eye and Lip Makeup Remover


Glossier Milky Jelly Cleanser

Clarins Instant

Clarins Instant Eye Makeup Remover

Dr Jart+ Dermaclear

Dr Jart+ Dermaclear Micro Water

Dior Instant

Dior Instant Eye Makeup Remover

  • We’re not discouraging you from using eye makeup remover! That would be just plain cruel.

However, it’s not as simple as going into a drugstore and picking out any old thing. It’s similar in that respect to buying soap. They do the same thing in the end, but there are stark differences that make or break them.

It can be challenging and time-consuming, as can be choosing the makeup you will eventually want to remove!

But it doesn’t have to be.

This list of the top twelve eye makeup removers is designed so that you can look at factors such as their ingredients, their application, how they react to certain skin types and what their speciality is.

By the end you’ll have a wealth of options to consider next time you are in need of eye makeup remover.

The 12 Best Eye Makeup Removers for Sensitive eyes Reviews

We’re sure that whatever your needs are, something on our list has the answer.

1. The Body Shop Camomile Gentle Eye Makeup Remover

The Body Shop Camomile

We’ll start with something that covers all the basics. This product boasts quick and easy removal of all makeup, and cleanses the skin afterwards. Your eyelashes will thank you while they’re being conditioned and cleaned.

There’s no overpowering oil or extra redundant ingredients in the mixture. Combined with its camomile essential oil base (not actually an oil!), The Body Shop has made a great gentle eye makeup remover. You know that you’ll be making an ethical choice as well by choosing The Body Shop.

2. MAC Gently Off Eye & Lip Makeup Remover


Gently Off doesn’t leave anything behind on your face. It will remove whatever you’ve got near your eyes: brow pencil, eyeliner and mascara. It will take out lipstick just as easily.

The best part is that MAC claims that you don’t need to rinse afterwards. It’s perfect as something to keep with you so that you can quickly banish makeup.

It’s tested by dermatologists and ophthalmologists and is very kind to acne-prone skin.

3. Nivea Double Effects Eye Makeup Remover


This is a perfect example of why Nivea is such a trusted household name. It’s got the signature dead-simple effect as any other Nivea products. This one doesn’t require any rubbing or scrubbing to remove makeup so there’s no chance that you’ll feel the excruciating sting of stray bits of chemicals in your eye.

Its availability and simplicity makes it the best drugstore eye makeup remover on this list.

4. NARS Gentle Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover


This is another waterproof eye makeup remover that uses camomile along with cucumber for good measure. It’s advertised as being designed to be especially effective on waterproof makeup. This is a big claim, but NARS has delivered.

It’s a successful combination of mildness and efficiency. It’s also one of those rare eye makeup removers which use oil, but you won’t get greasy after using this product.

This is all topped off with the fact that it requires little to no rubbing around the eyes.

5. Avon Moisture Effective Eye Makeup Remover Lotion


The next two on this list are from stalwarts of the makeup world. Avon’s take on makeup remover comes with a long list of features. You won’t need much for it to work, which means that you can use it for a substantial amount of time without having to restock.

It will moisturise and condition your eyelashes and skin as well. The best part is that it won’t leave a pesky film over your eyes or stick around long after you’ve removed your makeup.

6. L'Oréal Paris Gentle Eye Makeup Remover

L'Oréal Paris

Gentle by name, gentle by nature. This contains L'Oréal’s signature ‘Pro Vitamin’ ingredient. It’s not too descriptive of how it actually works, but whatever this ingredient does, it’s done well.

It meets all of the needs of a good eye makeup remover. No fuss or convoluted methods of application are to be found here. If you have sensitive skin, sensitive eyes or if you’re acne-prone, this is a very reasonable and readily available product.

7. Philosophy Purity Made Simple

Philosophy Purity

With rosewood, coconut and carrot extracts in the ingredient list, we’ve got another nice natural eye makeup remover here. They’re not just there to make it sound pretty. These small parts of the recipe add up to make an effective mixture which is more free of problematic chemicals. It’s also fragrance free, so you won’t have to hold your nose when applying it.

It’s known as one of the better hydrating makeup removers out there. Not wearing makeup? No problem! This is a brilliant facial cleanser as well and won’t irritate your sensitive skin.

8. Shiseido Instant Eye and Lip Makeup Remover


Shiseido has created a product which will give back as well as take away. The xylitol inside will help your skin retain its moisture. It will protect your lips and eye areas from dryness while removing whatever you’ve put on them.

This is the best eye makeup remover for waterproof mascara and sensitive eyes and it doesn’t take much of this at all to get even long-lasting makeup off. Use one more drop and you can remove anything you’re using on your lips.

This is the best gentle eye makeup remover out there due to its effectiveness even in small quantities.

9. Glossier Milky Jelly Cleanser


Sounds almost edible, right? All that milk and jelly? Maybe you can’t eat it but your skin will soak it up. This is a bit different from the others as it’s a gel. All it takes is a few rubs on the eye and a rinse to get rid of mascara.

Consisting of five essential skin conditioners, it works as a cleanser for the whole face as well, so you can use it to start your day with fresh and hydrated skin.

Glossier also sports some rosewater in its ingredients so you can enjoy its scent!

10. Clarins Instant Eye Makeup Remover


The phrase ‘heavy-duty’ comes to mind. There’s no pretense to be seen here. It’s designed specifically for long-lasting and waterproof makeup. There’s no rubbing or struggles to get that last dot out needed here. Don’t look at the ‘instant’ part of the name with skepticism either.

Hold it up to your eyes for a few seconds, you’ll find your makeup gone and your eyes moisturised in a matter of seconds. Some have taken issue with the latest edition of this one, as they’ve added a fragrance to the mix. Be safe in the knowledge that this isn’t going to affect its actual efficiency.

11. Dr Jart+ Dermaclear™ Micro Water

Dr Jart+ Dermaclear

The first thing to note about this one is that it is made up of 85 per cent mineral water and contains a staggering 90 per cent of natural ingredients. This means no oil to grease up your face and no stinging alcohol to dry out the sensitive skin around your eyes.

The activated hydrogen mineral water will moisturise your skin at the same time while getting all your makeup off your face. It sounds like a long fancy name, but it really just means that it’s water which is good for your skin!

This may just be the best eye makeup remover for sensitive eyes we’ve ever tried.

12. Dior Instant Eye Makeup Remover

Dior Instant Eye

This is another great product to come out of the fashion giant. You’d think that the makers of some of the best cosmetics out there would also provide an equally great way of getting it all off. They have delivered with this.

The term ‘instant’ is deservedly used here as well. All it takes is a shake of the bottle to activate its bi-phase formula and a couple of seconds pressed gently on the skin.

Dior assures that this product is tested by ophthalmologists so you know your eyes will be safe and sound.

  • That’s our top twelve best eye makeup removers!
  • Experiment with different types of makeup with any of the above products and see how they compare.

    You might be surprised at how effective they might be when dealing with long-lasting, waterproof or normal makeup.

    Hopefully we’ve helped you realise that eye makeup remover is in essence very easy to choose once you know what you want in them and what you don’t want.

    Now, go out and enjoy the confidence that even if your best makeup efforts are thwarted, you have the tools to start again with confidence. Go out knowing that if you need to get something off straight away, you will know exactly what to use!

What is the best eye makeup remover you’ve ever used? Do you have any tips or tricks? Did we leave something out of our list?

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below